This is a chronological list of restaurants permanently closed in Springfield, Illinois—a nostalgic look back and a helpful resource for those seeking available restaurant spaces. These are the places that we miss. This is our restaurant history. A forgotten piece of our heritage. No matter how long each of these eateries were open, on a daily basis they paid someone’s rent, provided sustenance for a hungry traveler, or were just part of the community. So please join us and do not forget this part of our town.
Springfield, Illinois, with a population of around 114,000, is nestled in the heart of the American Midwest. Known for its rich history as the home of Abraham Lincoln, the city boasts a vibrant food scene that pays homage to its local traditions. One standout dish is the iconic “Springfield-style” pizza, characterized by its unique thin crust and blend of toppings, including an abundance of fresh vegetables and meats. The historic Palermo’s, a beloved local restaurant, has been serving up this delicacy for decades, reflecting the city’s Italian heritage. Springfield’s geographical location, surrounded by fertile farmland, also contributes to its farm-to-table movement, with many eateries showcasing locally sourced ingredients in their dishes. This connection to the land, along with its fascinating history, makes Springfield a flavorful destination for food lovers.
Are you looking for a restaurant job in Springfield, Illinois?
Disclaimer: The information on this website is provided as a resource, but it may not always be 100% accurate. While we strive to research and verify details, errors can occur, and businesses frequently change names, locations, or reopen after closing. Addresses, operating status, and other details may be outdated or incorrect. Use this information at your own risk. If you spot an error, please contact us here, and we will do our best to update it promptly.
Closed Down Restaurants in Springfield, Illinois
A capital city full of stories — one meal at a time.
From Route 66 diners and beloved steak joints to franchise giants and mom-and-pop treasures, Springfield has seen a lot of restaurants come and go. Some lasted decades; others just a few years. All of them, however, played a role in the social and culinary fabric of Illinois’ capital.
Below is a decade-by-decade breakdown of Springfield’s most notable restaurant closures.
2020s
Alexander’s Steakhouse
Closed: Late 2023
A longstanding local favorite where diners grilled their own steaks. Known for its casual atmosphere and custom-cut meats.
Loukinens’ on 4th
Closed: Late 2023
An upscale restaurant with a loyal following, known for elegant presentation and fresh ingredients.
Di Piero’s Sicilian Cucina (Downtown Springfield)
Closed: December 28, 2024
Opened in 2019 near the Old State Capitol Plaza. Pandemic struggles and declining foot traffic contributed to its closure.
Howard Johnson’s (3190 S Dirksen Pkwy)
Demolished: 2021
Previously a Steak N Shake, the building was demolished and replaced by a Starbucks.
Bennigan’s (700 E Adams St)
Closed: Date unknown
Later became Urban Grille. The space is now vacant.
Hooters (3241 Horizon Dr)
Closed: Date unknown
Known for wings and sports. The location is no longer in operation.
2000s
Chi-Chi’s (2151 Wabash Ave)
Closed: 2004
A once-popular Mexican chain. The building now houses a restaurant and bakery.
1990s and Earlier
Howard Johnson’s (1025 S 5th St)
Closed: Date unknown
Now occupied by Chicago Title. The adjacent hotel is being converted into apartments.
Parkview Supper Club (3073 E Clear Lake Ave)
Opened: 1982
Later became Mario’s Pizza. Currently closed.
Stach’s Restaurant and Lounge (2441 S MacArthur Blvd)
Opened: 1982
Later replaced by Diamonds Buffet Restaurant.
Chuck E. Cheese’s Pizza Time Theatre (1766 Wabash Ave)
Opened: 1982
Now an Off Track Betting Shop.
The Same Old Shillelagh (951 S Durkin Dr)
Opened: 1982
Now Lime Street Cafe.
Show Biz Pizza Place (2369 S MacArthur Blvd)
Opened: 1982
Eventually merged into the Chuck E. Cheese brand, which now occupies the space.
The Ground Round (1975 Wabash Ave)
Opened: 1982
Now an Irish Pub called The Dublin Pub.
Judy’s Place (425 E Washington St)
Opened: 1982
Later believed to have served as an attorney’s office.
Tony’s Pastaroni’s (3185 S Dirksen Pkwy)
Opened: 1982
Current status unclear; now appears to be a hotel site.
Glass Terrace (1200 Capital Airport Dr)
Opened: 1982
Once a dining establishment, no longer in operation.
Frances Italian Pizza, Etc. (2128 N Peoria Rd)
Opened: 1982
The site no longer houses a restaurant.
Mama Sans Oriental Restaurant (1200 S 13th St)
Opened: 1982
Now surrounded by residences; the building no longer operates as a dining space.
Ben’s Place (1601 E Converse St)
Opened: 1982
Closed in the early 2000s. Replaced by Little Corner Bar and Converse Street Bar.
Red Lobster (2696 S Dirksen Pkwy)
Opened: 1982
Originally part of Inns of America; its current status is unclear.
Tops Big Boy (Multiple Locations)
Opened: 1982
-
Grand Ave E & S 5th St – Status unknown
-
Washington St & Chatham Rd – Status unknown
Dublin Pub was once The Ground Round
Other 1980s Favorites:
-
Magic Recipes (2943 W Chinden Blvd, Garden City)
-
Twin Dragon Restaurant (2200 Fairview Ave)
-
Eddie’s Fine Foods (3900 W Overland Rd)
Final Thoughts
From Pizza Time Theatres to Big Boy burgers and Sicilian-style pastas downtown, Springfield’s food scene is filled with ghosts of good meals past. These restaurants were gathering places—birthday dinner spots, late-night coffee hangouts, and first-date destinations.
Did we miss a place you remember fondly? Share your memories and photos at ClosedDownRestaurants.com.
Comments