This is a chronological list of restaurants permanently closed in South Bend, Indiana—a nostalgic look back and a helpful resource for those seeking available restaurant spaces. These are the places that we miss. This is our restaurant history—a forgotten piece of our heritage. No matter how long each of these eateries was open, they contributed to someone’s rent, provided sustenance for a hungry traveler, or were simply part of the community. So please join us and do not forget this part of our town.
South Bend, Indiana, home to a vibrant population of around 101,000, is nestled along the banks of the St. Joseph River in the heart of the Midwest. This city boasts a rich culinary heritage influenced by its diverse immigrant communities, with notable dishes like the iconic South Bend-style pizza known for its unique crust and flavorful toppings. A standout in the local food scene is *The Carriage House*, celebrated for its farm-to-table approach and sumptuous comfort food. South Bend’s history as a manufacturing hub and proximity to agricultural lands has fostered a deep-rooted appreciation for locally-sourced ingredients, creating a delicious blend of tradition and innovation in its ever-evolving food landscape.
Are you looking for a restaurant job in South Bend, Indiana?
Disclaimer: The information on this website is provided as a resource, but it may not always be 100% accurate. While we strive to research and verify details, errors can occur, and businesses frequently change names, locations, or reopen after closing. Addresses, operating status, and other details may be outdated or incorrect. Use this information at your own risk. If you spot an error, please contact us here, and we will do our best to update it promptly.
Closed Down Restaurants in South Bend, Indiana
From Notre Dame tailgates to downtown suppers — a look at South Bend’s dining history through the places we’ve lost.
South Bend’s food scene has always reflected its community: resilient, nostalgic, and quietly evolving. Whether it was a family-run diner or a mid-century Howard Johnson’s, many former staples of the city have served their last plate — but they haven’t been forgotten.
Here’s a citywide rundown of notable restaurant closures, sorted by decade, from the oldest legacies to recent departures.
2020s
Howard Pork (near Howard Park)
Closed: August 2024
Known for smoked meats and brisket tacos, this modern BBQ restaurant operated for less than a year before shutting down.
Aspen Tap House (Mishawaka)
Closed: March 2025
A family-friendly bar and grill on Main Street, its closure came with a heartfelt thank-you message to loyal patrons.
McDonald’s (Lincoln Way West)
Closed: November 2023
This location near South Bend International Airport closed abruptly, sparking conversation in the community.
2010s
J. Willy’s (Mishawaka)
Closed: 2015 (Demolished)
Featured on Kitchen Nightmares, the restaurant couldn’t survive despite TV fame.
The Emporium
Closed: Early 2020s
A classic riverfront restaurant that was especially popular for dates and celebrations.
TGI Friday’s (South Bend & Mishawaka locations)
Closed: During the COVID-19 pandemic
National closures hit the area’s two locations hard.
Ponderosa Steakhouse
Closed: 2020–2021
All area locations of this buffet chain shut down during the pandemic.
2000s–1980s
Bonnie Doon Drive-In (219 W. LaSalle Ave)
Opened: 1939
Closed: Date unknown
A nostalgic favorite, famous for root beer and carhop service.
Robertson’s Tea Room (Michigan Street)
Closed: Late 20th century
Located atop the old Robertson’s Department Store downtown, this elegant tearoom was a part of the city’s retail history.
The Philadelphia (116 N. Michigan St)
Closed: 1972
A South Bend staple that began in 1901 — known for confections, soda fountains, and family meals.
Historic Howard Johnson’s Closures
-
52965 State Hwy 933 – Transformed into a Steak ’n Shake
-
Other historic HoJo’s – Many locations across South Bend and Mishawaka have since been replaced, repurposed, or demolished.
1960s Legacy — The “October 31, 1965” Openings
In an interesting twist of timing, many beloved South Bend restaurants shared the same opening date: October 31, 1965. Some remain open, while others live on only in memory:
-
Burger Chef (4920 W Western Ave) – Now a local family-run eatery
-
Sunny Italy Café (601 N. Niles Ave) – Still operating today
-
Frankie’s (1003 N. Notre Dame Ave) – Continues to serve the community
-
Walt’s Restaurant (4203 S Michigan St) – Status unknown
-
Russ’s Fine Food (3222 Lincoln Way West) – Status unknown
-
Azar’s (LWE & Ironwood Dr) – No longer in operation
-
Garrett’s (US 20 & Liberty Dr, Mishawaka) – Closed
-
The Country Squire – Address unknown; believed closed
-
The Ranch House – Address unknown; presumed closed
Honorable Mentions & Forgotten Favorites
-
The Moderne (110 W. Washington St) – A soda fountain and candy shop now lost to time.
-
The Louvered Door (1622 W Western Ave) – Now permanently closed.
-
The Red Coach Grill (Downtown South Bend) – A fine dining spot of the mid-20th century.
Final Thoughts
From hot roast beef sandwiches to juke boxes and drive-ins, the restaurants of South Bend reflect a living memory of the city’s heartbeat. If you have memories, photos, or stories from any of these restaurants — share them on ClosedDownRestaurants.com and help preserve the legacy of these places.
Comments