Honeoye, New York Restaurant Closures and Closed Restaurants

Welcome to Honeoye, New York, a quaint lakeside community with a population of 2,458 nestled in the Finger Lakes region. Known for its stunning natural beauty and proximity to Honeoye Lake, this charming town has seen several dining spots come and go. Here, we highlight the closed down restaurants that have permanently closed or temporarily closed their doors, offering a glimpse into the culinary history that once thrived in our beloved town.

Disclaimer: The information on this website is provided as a resource, but it may not always be 100% accurate. While we strive to research and verify details, errors can occur, and businesses frequently change names, locations, or reopen after closing. Addresses, operating status, and other details may be outdated or incorrect. Use this information at your own risk. If you spot an error, please contact us here, and we will do our best to update it promptly.


Love old restaurant stories, local history, and keeping up with the places that quietly disappear? Our free weekday emails follow restaurant closures across the entire United States—one region at a time— with short stories, links, and context you won’t see in a headline. Sign up once, and you’ll get a quick tour of what closed this week, Monday through Friday.

    • 🌵 Southwest StoriesMonday
      Texas · New Mexico · Arizona · Oklahoma
    • 🌾 Midwest FarewellTuesday
      Iowa · Illinois · Indiana · Ohio · Michigan · Minnesota · Wisconsin · Missouri · Kansas · Nebraska · North Dakota · South Dakota
    • 🌤 Southern Last CallWednesday
      Louisiana · Mississippi · Alabama · Georgia · Florida · South Carolina · North Carolina · Tennessee · Kentucky · West Virginia · Arkansas
    • 🌊 Coastline ClosingsThursday
      California · Oregon · Washington · Alaska · Hawaii
    • 🏔 Mountain West ReportFriday
      Idaho · Montana · Wyoming · Colorado · Utah · Nevada
    • 🍁 New England NotesSaturday
      Maine · Vermont · New Hampshire · Massachusetts · Rhode Island · Connecticut
    • 🏙 Mid-Atlantic MemoSunday Morning
      New York · New Jersey · Pennsylvania · Delaware · Maryland · Washington, D.C.
Mill Creek Cafe – Honeoye – 8705 Main St
8705 Main St
Honeoye, NY 14471
Status: Permanently Closed
Subway – Honeoye – 10 Honeoye Rd
10 Honeoye Rd
Honeoye, NY 14471
Status: Permanently Closed