This is a chronological list of restaurants permanently closed in Casselberry, Florida—a nostalgic look back and a helpful resource for those seeking available restaurant spaces. These are the places that we miss. This is our restaurant history. A forgotten piece of our heritage. No matter how long each of these eateries were open, on a daily basis they paid someone’s rent, provided sustenance for a hungry traveler, or were just part of the community. So please join us and do not forget this part of our town.
Casselberry, Florida, a vibrant city with a population of around 27,000, is nestled in the heart of Central Florida, just north of Orlando. The city’s food scene reflects its multicultural influences, featuring a fusion of Southern comfort foods and Hispanic flavors. Notable local dishes include empanadas, fried plantains, and barbecue pulled pork, often enjoyed at community gatherings. One standout restaurant, **The Urban Turban**, brings a unique twist to traditional Indian cuisine with its popular fusion dishes like curry burritos. Located near the scenic shores of Lake Concord, Casselberry’s culinary landscape is enriched by its history as a citrus-growing hub, allowing for fresh, local ingredients that enhance the region’s renowned dishes.
Are you looking for a restaurant job in Casselberry, Florida?
Disclaimer: The information on this website is provided as a resource, but it may not always be 100% accurate. While we strive to research and verify details, errors can occur, and businesses frequently change names, locations, or reopen after closing. Addresses, operating status, and other details may be outdated or incorrect. Use this information at your own risk. If you spot an error, please contact us here, and we will do our best to update it promptly.
Closed Down Restaurants in Casselberry, Florida
A Taste of What Once Was in This Orlando-Area Suburb
From fondue and fajitas to classic chains and family-owned spots, Casselberry has seen many restaurants come and go. While new eateries continue to open, these now-closed restaurants once shaped the local flavor. Here’s a look back at some of the city’s most notable closures.
2020s
V’s Vegan Diner
Location: 908 State Road 436
Closure Date: June 2024
After a public plea for community support, this plant-based diner closed its doors in mid-2024. It was one of the few all-vegan options in the area.
Breakfast Club of Casselberry
Location: 3385 S US Highway 17-92, Suite 189
Closure Date: August 2023 (temporarily)
Temporarily shuttered due to health code violations, its long-term status remains uncertain.
2010s and Earlier (No Exact Date)
Palma Maria
Closure Date: January 2020
A beloved Italian family restaurant that closed after decades in business, following the loss of a key family member.
Amelia’s Italian Restaurant
Status: Closed (Date unknown)
Reported closed by multiple patrons, this restaurant was known for its classic red-sauce dishes and warm hospitality.
Roadhouse Grill
Location: 1870 State Rd 436
Status: Closed (Date unknown)
This grill-style chain location has since shuttered, marking another lost national chain presence.
Don Pablo’s
Location: 900 FL-436
Status: Now a Buffalo Wild Wings
Once known for its Tex-Mex and festive décor, this location has changed hands, now serving wings instead of enchiladas.
Hooters
Location: 2699 Cassel Creek Blvd
Status: Closed
Part of a nationwide contraction of the brand, this Hooters quietly disappeared from the Casselberry food scene.
1990s
Chi-Chi’s
Location: 160 FL-436
Closure Date: 1995
Known for its Mexican dishes and festive atmosphere, Chi-Chi’s was once a household name across the U.S. before the brand’s decline.
1980s
The Fresher Cooker
Location: 111 Semoran Blvd
Closure Date: 1984
A quirky and memorable name, this restaurant served classic American fare before becoming a medical office.
1970s
Fondue Factory & Pub
Location: FL-436 & Howell Branch Rd
Opened: 1977
This fondue destination was part of a 1970s dining trend, offering a retro night-out vibe.
Date Unknown
Bennigan’s
Location: 1385 FL-436
Status: Now a BioLife Plasma Center
This Irish-American bar and grill was once famous for its Monte Cristo sandwiches and weekday happy hours.
Final Thoughts
Casselberry’s dining history reflects both national trends and local charm. Whether you remember The Fresher Cooker or miss the smell of fajitas at Don Pablo’s, these places live on in local memory.
To explore more Florida restaurant history—or to share a memory of your own—visit Closed Down Restaurants.com.
Comments